HSA vs Traditional Calculation

Health Savings Account (HSA) vs. Traditional Health Plan

This tool is designed to help you compare an High Deductible Health Plan (HDHP) with a Health Savings Account (HSA) to a traditional health plan. By using HDHP/HSA solution, you can often realize significant savings on your insurance premiums and receive a deduction on your income taxes. Use this calculator to determine the possible savings.

Back To Use More Calculators    


Annual prescriptions
Number of prescriptions you expect to fill annually.

Annual doctor visits
Number of times you expect to visit the doctors office annually.

Marginal income tax rate
Use the table below to help you choose the appropriate federal marginal income tax rate.


Filing Status and Income Tax Rates 2008

Tax rate Married filing jointly
or Qualified Widow(er)
Single Head of household Married filing separately
10% $0 - 16,050 $0 - 8,025 $0 - $11,450 $0 - 8,025
15% $16,051- 65,100 $8,026- 32,550 $11,451- 43,650 $8,026- 32,550
25% $65,101- 131,450 $32,551- 78,850 $43,651- 112,650 $32,551- 65,725
28% $131,451- 200,300 $78,851- 164,550 $112,651- 182,400 $65,726- 100,150
33% $200,301- 357,700 $164,551- 357,700 $182,401- 357,700 $100,151- 178,850
35% over $357,700 over $357,700 over $357,700 over $178,850

Monthly premium
Monthly premuim for your proposed health insurance options.

Annual deductible
Annual deductible that you are required to pay before your health insurance begins coverage. We assume that after this threshold has been reached that your insurance covers 100% of your expenses. In 2008, for a HDHP, the minimum deductible amount is $1,100 for self-only coverage and $2,200 for family coverage.

Maximum annual out-of-pocket
Maximum out-of-pocket in a given year for your health insurance. This is the maximum total expense that you could incur in a given year with your proposed coverage. In 2008, for a HDHP, the highest annual out-of-pocket expense allowed is $5,600/individual coverage and $11,200/family coverage for 2008.

Co–pay for doctor visits and prescriptions
The fee you pay for each prescription and/or doctors visit. These payments do not count toward your annual deductible or your maximum out of pocket expense.

The percentage of your healthcare costs that your insurance will cover after your costs exceed your annual deductible. You are assumed to continue to pay this percentage of your healthcare costs until you reach your annual maximum out of pocket expense.

Other expenses
Any other expenses that would normally be covered by your health insurance. This would include lab fees and services other than prescriptions and doctor visits. Don't include medical expenses not normally covered by your insurance such as some elective surgery, contact lens solution or over the counter medications.

HSA Contributions
Total you expect to contribute to an HSA account per year. All contributions to a HSA account are tax deductible and withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are not subject to income tax. For 2016, the maximum contribution to a HSA is $3,350 for self-only coverage and $6,750 for family coverage.

HSA current balance
Total amount you have in an existing HSA account. If you do not have an HSA plan at this time this amount should be $0.